Friday, April 10, 2020

Back To The Future

Get used to it you birders. This is the dystopian, authoritarian future. The current lockdown is just a dress rehearsal for the real thing of the not too distant future. 

The Department for Transport has launched a consultation paper which calls for a major move from cars into cycling, walking and buses, but has told few people about it. 

The paper, Decarbonising Transport: Setting the Challenge, crept out on March 26. Citing the Government’s 2050 net-zero greenhouse-gas emissions target, Transport Secretary Grant Shapps writes of a vision where - “Public transport and active travel will be the natural first choice for our daily activities. We will use our cars less and be able to rely on a convenient, cost-effective and coherent public transport network.” 

He adds: “From motorcycles to HGVs, all road vehicles will be zero emission and technological advances . . . will change the way vehicles are used.” 

How will the reduction in private transport be achieved? By making private cars too expensive for ordinary people? Rationing cars to one per family? Rationing mileage  by road charging? Or maybe we will end up with scenes observed this week, where the authorities allow car travel for specific purposes only? Or more worryingly, cars for elite sections of society only - politicians by any chance? 

Animal Farm

Fortunately, happier thoughts are to be found in Another Bird Blog archives from December 2014 when I asked the question “Do Birds Smell?”.


It’s a question I asked myself a number of years ago when noting how long it took for birds to discover new sources of food, in particular the introduction of bird feeders where none had been used previously. 

Birds were always thought to have a very poor sense of smell. But most vultures and many scavenging seabirds locate their food by smell. Any birder who has been on a pelagic trip to see seabirds up close will be familiar with the practice of chucking overboard buckets of “chum” or “rubby-dubby”, to lure shearwaters and petrels close to the boat. 

Manx Shearwater

Wilson's Storm Petrel

Scientists believe that other birds, e.g. homing pigeons, may use familiar odours in finding their way home or use their sense of smell during migratory journeys. Think about the various odours given off to overflying birds by different places, e.g. pine forest or ancient deciduous woodland, saline or fresh water, the urban jungle or the countryside. 

Egyptian Vulture 

A recent Dutch study determined that Great Tits found and located apple trees with winter moth infestations and big concentrations of caterpillar larvae by smell rather than sight. Tit species eat large numbers of insect larvae particularly during their breeding seasons when they feed them to their young, timing their breeding to do so. Trees benefit from the protection offered by birds removing larvae that would otherwise go on to eat the leaves and perhaps impact on tree growth and productivity 

Great Tit 

The Dutch experiments were designed to remove other possible ways in which the Great Tits might detect the winter moth larvae. The researchers removed the caterpillars, removed leaves with holes and even took away signs of ‘caterpillar poo’, ensuring no visual clues were left for the birds to locate the infested trees. Despite these measures the Great Tits repeatedly found the trees with larvae infestations. 

The results were clear, even when they couldn’t see the trees, the Great Tits homed in on trees with winter moth infestations when they could smell them. The researchers believe the trees gave off chemicals which birds can detect by smell to alert them to infestation. It has long been known that many plants attract insects using smells and benefit from the relationships as a result, but this is the first time they have been shown to attract birds in the same way. 

More research is needed to determine which chemicals are involved but infested trees were found to release more of a chemical responsible for the “green” smell of apples. 

Most bird feeders use metal/plastic tubes or wire mesh to make the food highly visible to birds and we naturally assume that birds start to use our bird feeders because they locate food via their keen eyesight. My new niger seed feeders arrived today, replacements for ones recently stolen from a ringing site. At first glance the design looks improbable and unlikely to work as the feeding holes are tiny. When the stainless steel cylinder is filled with niger, the seed is virtually invisible with just the tiniest point of an individual seed poking through a hole. 

Bird Feeders 

Nevertheless I experimented with this design of feeder a number of years ago and found them to be highly successful in attracting Goldfinches, Siskins and Lesser Redpolls very quickly and I attributed some of this to the birds’ ability to smell the seed. 


Here’s an experiment anyone can try at home. Buy a sealed bag of niger seed, open the bag and stick your nose in it. Then inhale and enjoy the sweet, oily, nutty fragrance which brings in those Goldfinches 

There’s is no doubt in my mind that birds and in particular Goldfinches have well developed olfactory senses, probably as good as our own. 

Now you must excuse me. From the kitchen I detect the unmistakable aroma of a tandoori chicken sizzling on the grill. 

Tandoori Chicken

I'm ready for a bite to eat. Back soon with more tasty morsels from the past.

Linking today with Anni's Blog and Eileen's Saturday Blog.


Mike Attwood said...

Thanks Phil for that info, I learned a lot and gave me something to think about. Stay safe, Mike.

Anu said...

Hello Phil. Interesting post. Thank you.

Elkes Lebensglück said...

Very interesting your report and great photos. It makes you think and it has to be that way. Anyone who is not greedy for money would like to change that for the good of the nature we need to live.

Happy Easter and stay healthy, Elke

italiafinlandia said...

Happy Easter, Philand thanks for this post.
I love tandoori chicken too...

eileeninmd said...


Interesting post, I am sure things will need to be done differently in the future. Hubby and I have already downsized to one car, with the lockdown we rarely use it. The bird photos are lovely, The Manx Shearwater is a gorgeous bird. I like the feeder, love the Goldfinches. The chicken looks delicious.

Thank you so much for linking up and sharing your post. Take care,stay well!

Enjoy your weekend, Happy Easter!

Stevenson Q said...

Hello Phil! First of all, I would love a piece of that Chicken Tandoori thank you very much. That Manx Shearwater looks very magical and reminds me of the film Frozen. How those white feathers look perfectly placed by where the water ends make it look like it's being frozen by the river, I love it! And about that Aminal Farm strip, that is very much interesting and true, well talking about the Philippines and how a Covid positive Senator who breached quarantine and went to the hospital recklessly to see his wife give birth was not jailed not even reprimanded because he is an ally of the executive while the poor who went out of the house just because they're looking for food were all jailed.

Anyway, sorry to share that negative news, I really wish you a happy and meaningful Easter and I want to thank you for your kind words about the Philippines on my blog, that means so much! Despite the things that are happening here, my country is blessed with amazing landscapes that you will surely enjoy, visit our islands soon Phil!


Linda aka Crafty Gardener said...

If only there was public transport where I live, I would happily use it.
I love seeing the goldfinches you have over the pond, here ours are all yellow and black.

sandyland said...

how prvalent are blue biRds?? i long to see

Anni said...

Someone stole feeders? That is the epitome of stupidity.

Have a blessed Easter Phil. (visiting here today makes me think of your is he doing? Improving, I hope)

Adam Jones said...

Phil, I'm pretending I didn't read the first half of your post, but have absorbed the second half completely. Lovely shots too of the Storm Petrol and Manx Shearwater.

Wally Jones said...

Communique from the Rebel Alliance across the pond.

We are fortunate our current Governor of Florida has not yet lost his mind and urges all the state's citizens use common sense (quite an assumption we all have it!). No mandatory lock-down, yet.

Throughout the U.S. there are others who see opportunity to force various agendas upon the populace. We are truly being tested.

To add to your Animal Farm theme:

“No one believes more firmly than Comrade Napoleon that all animals are equal. He would be only too happy to let you make your decisions for yourselves. But sometimes you might make the wrong decisions, comrades, and then where should we be?”
― George Orwell, Animal Farm

Your post from 2014 on the olfactory senses of birds was very interesting. I'll be spending the rest of this pot of coffee researching the subject.

Your actual question, "Do Birds Smell?", may have been answered by one of America's founding fathers, Benjamin Franklin, who said: "Guests, like fish, begin to smell after three days." Perhaps birds fall into that category.

Your chicken looks fantastic and I believe my own olfactory senses may be extraordinary as I can detect the aroma through the computer monitor.

Be well. Don't poke your nose outside unless you must go for food, medicine or spring migrant!

likeschocolate said...

Of course, you did have to finish with a lovely Indian dinner and now I am hungry. Sadly, the Indian food in our are is too spicy. Most of the Indians who live near us are from the south and the south and they love spice.

Stewart M said...

I was amazed how quickly sea birds respond to 'chum' - although I must admit it really does stink!!

Hope you are well - Stewart M - Melbourne

Powell River Books said...

I often wonder what will happen for driving on forestry back roads like we do frequently. Living off the grid without a heavy duty power source will make having all electric vehicles a challenge. - Margy

Fun60 said...

A very interesting post with brilliant photos as always.

Carol @Comfort Spring Station said...

Great pictures, take care

Hootin' Anni said...

I didn't realize B Johnson was so critical. Hope he continues to improve. And, thanks for linking up.

Related Posts with Thumbnails