Monday, July 2, 2018

Twitchers are Losers?

Isn't it good to see a little controversy in the birding world now and then? Even if it's an old chestnut. 

From 10,000 Birds June 30th 2018. Twitchers are Losers.


"Everyone likes to see a rare bird. Whether it’s new for your life list, country list, state list, or county list, a new bird is a joy, a blessing. But listing, especially in a limited geographical area, is a game of diminishing returns. After all, once you have checked a bird off of your checklist there is no checking it again (unless you are into year listing). What’s a motivated lister to do? Some folks who are really into listing figure out what birds they still need for their list that are still at least theoretically possible to see and come up with strategies to see them. They wait for the winds to be right for a lake watch, sea watch, or hawk watch. They put themselves in the lines of hurricanes. They get to migrant traps that are perfect under certain conditions at the time of year that their quarry is most likely to arrive. And, most importantly, they never stop searching. 

Other listers turn to the dark side. They lurk on listservs, ogle eBird, follow Facebook, tempt themselves on Twitter. They wait for others to find birds and they chase them. That is, they twitch. Instead of seeking out their own discoveries they follow in the footsteps of others and seek out species already seen. 

Now, don’t get me wrong. I might have been known to twitch. But the more I bird the less I feel the need to chase after other birder’s finds. I like birding my local patches and when I find the occasional mini-rarity it gives me far more of a thrill than seeing a bird in the company of dozens. Almost every birder has chased at least one bird at some point and that’s alright. But if you are exclusively chasing, constantly twitching birds others have found and not patch birding on the regular, not introducing others to birding, not contributing to conservation, you are not just failing birds and the birding community but you are, pretty much, a loser. 

After all, the real winners in birding are the ones who find the rarities. They win the accolades and admiration. Everyone will remember from now until we all die that it was Matt Daw who found the Rufous-necked Wood Rail. But no one really cares about the twitcher who saw it. Even on a large scale, twitching is becoming less admired. Yes, birders still do Big Years in limited geographical areas but the ABA-Area Big Year, twitch-heavy affair that it has become, is less impressive now that the World Big Year has become a thing. If the world is your playing field the only rarities you might chase are rare on a global scale in that they are Critically Endangered, not dirt-common birds that wandered off course. 

Twitchers consume vast quantities of fuel and contribute to climate change. They help perpetuate a not-very-flattering image of birding. And for every study about how much money a twitch contributes to a local economy – money that would probably have been better spent on something besides gasoline and fast food – I’ll show you a story about a brouhaha that erupted when misbehaving twitchers spoiled relations between local birders and their community. 

So twitch less and bird local patches more. Lead walks for your local bird club or Audubon Society. Show kids birds. Volunteer for conservation organizations. Just ease up on the twitching, loser."

Comments now folks.

Back to ringing tomorrow on Another Bird Blog.

Very soon I will post a review of the new book by Katrina van Grouw, Unnatural Selection. It's a winner!



eileeninmd said...

Hello, I always love to see a new bird. At one time I have been known to chase a few. Not any more, even if it is rare or new to my state. I stopped keeping track of my lifer list. Now, I am just enjoying the birds I see.

Enjoy your day and new week ahead. Happy July!

David M. Gascoigne, said...

Good afternoon Phil: Twitchers are indeed losers - not in the pejorative sense one might normally apply that epithet - but losers because they do not take the time to appreciate the organism they are twitching.The chronic lister - for whom the list is everything - will never have his curiosity piqued by the bird he has travelled so far to see; he will not have the urge to get home to his reference material as quickly as possible to delve into the life history of the bird. Where did it come from? Why is it so far from home? What is the breeding cycle? How about moult? Is it likely to reorient and get back to where it should be? Nope, for twitchers everywhere it is just another check mark on a list. Might as well be a train spotter or a twitcher of signs on cream bun shops. Twitchers are losers again and again - big time!

Patrycja P. said...

Hi Phil,
I think that every birder sometimes “twitches”. And, thanks to the twiching, we also can learn more about birds. I don’t criticise twitchers unless they harm birds.

Stewart M said...

Each to their own I suppose - but it's not really for me.

Cheers - Stewart M - Melbourne

Lowcarb team member said...

I'm just so pleased to see birds that are local to me …

All the best Jan

Related Posts with Thumbnails